ONE DAY by
David Nicholls
My rating :
4.5 of
5 stars
There are certain books, apart from the instant best-seller types, that generate a certain buzz prior to release and immediately thereafter. The problem with the advance hype is that sometimes it can lead to markedly high expectations and utter disappointment.
One Day, which was released in England prior to publication in the U.S. in June of this year, had earned praise from critics and writers alike. As a result, it was with mild trepidation that I started this book, hoping for the best, but fearing the worst. I needn't have worried. I
loved this book.
On the night of their university graduation in Edinburgh, moneyed, stylish, Dexter Mayhew and spectacle-wearing, socially conscious Emma Morley, take their friendship to a new level when they realize their attraction for each other. As Emma goes off to make a difference in the world, Dexter flits about Europe, indulging in sexual and drunken escapades. They keep in touch over the years, while each tries to find his or her place in life, and the reader is given a glimpse into their lives on the yearly anniversary of that fateful graduation night. Hence, the "One Day" of the title.
Through the years, Dexter and Emma rise and fall in pursuing careers and happiness, and often one is up at a moment of the other's failure. At first it is Emma who struggles, and then as the years go by, it is Dexter who flounders, descending into drug and alcohol related problems just as Emma has pulled her life together. At various times, they are the victims of a series of missed connections, letters and phone calls that might have made a difference in the way their relationship progressed. In telling their story Nicholls has an uncanny ability to evoke the awkward feelings, and general uncomfortableness between these two individuals despite their underlying attraction.
But it is not just in casting the romantic aspect of the relationship that Nicholls is so spot on: it is his ability to capture the yearning that Dex and Emma have to live that life that they saw for themselves at graduation --that bigger life that we all think we are going to lead when we're young. His portrayal of Dexter's anxieties about aging -- the insecurity and horror he experiences upon realizing that he is turning into a suburbanized version of his former urban playboy self -- is priceless.
The device of re-visiting the principals on the same day each year sounded like such an unworkable gimmick to me, but I was so wrong. It is fascinating to me how well the device works, without having any idea how it does. After reading the first few paragraphs of each chapter, the reader knows exactly where these two are in their lives without a lengthy, boring chronology of the year before. And at the end of each chapter, I was left wanting to know where they would be when the story took up again. Finally, the resolution of the story is just perfect...sad, but perfect.
There are already plans to make a movie of this, but I can unequivocally say that I will not see it. I loved this book too much to allow anyone else to interpret it for me. Dexter and Emma are very real to me, and I want to keep my vision of them for myself.
I highly highly recommend this book.
I received an ARC of One Dayfrom the publisher, Vintage Books, a division of Random House, Inc.